David Orr’s review of The Warrior: A Mother’s Story of a Son at War, a new book of poems by Frances Richey, in Sunday’s New York Times Book Review, quickly turns into a meditation on the role of the personal in modern poetry, but it might just as easily be a reflection on our need to construct frames through which to view any art. The book, as Orr notes, “reportedly sold at auction for a solid six figures,” an astonishing sum for a book of poetry. (As Orr points out, that’s “approximately five figures more than most poets could ever expect to see from a collection.” And have the words “auction” and “poetry” ever occurred in the same sentence?) Orr speculates that the book’s publisher, Viking, has invested not in the poems themselves but in what Hollywood calls the back story: the book offers Richey’s reflections on her relationship with her son, a Green Beret and West Point graduate who served two tours in Iraq. That’s quite a hook, and Richey’s “memoir in verse” gives us all the wrenching emotion for which publishers of the contemporary memoir hunger. A poem like “Kill School” is all act and feeling, the son’s emotionless narrative of learning to kill contrasted with his mother’s silent response:
The trainer showed him
how to rock the rabbitlike a baby in his arms,
faster and faster,until every sinew surrendered
and he smashed its head into a tree.They make a little squeaking sound,
he said. They cry.He drove as he told me:
You said you wanted to know.I didn’t ask how he felt.
Maybe I should have,but I was biting
off the skin from my lips,looking out
beyond the glittering lineof traffic flying
past us in the dark.
Of course, Richey’s gesture of (literally) biting her lips is a mother’s response, while the poet’s is to gaze out of the car window at the metaphoric closure forming around them. There’s a doubleness about these poems, which are simultaneously emotionally raw and . . . I started to write “polished,” but that’s not the word exactly, since it implies a specific quality of verse. Savvy, perhaps. Richey’s website includes a photo gallery that begins with Richey cradling her newborn son, then shows his progress from happy child to proud soldier, along with a blog in which the author shares stories sent in by readers who have their own experiences of families affected by the war. It’s moving, but also thoroughly professional, exactly what you’d expect from a best-selling memoirist. Her list of personal appearances includes stops at West Point, the Special Forces Senior Spouse Conference at Fort Bragg, North Carolina, as well as the Barnes & Noble on the Upper West Side of Manhattan. Poems from the book, her author bio notes, “have appeared in a two-page spread in O, The Oprah Magazine, Nicholas Kristof’s New York Times column, on the Lives page of the New York Times Magazine, and the local PBS show ‘New York Voices.’”


